Tag: road safety

  • Cycling for a living: The untold realities 

    Cycling for a living: The untold realities 

    Delivery cycling in Dublin, and the overlooked challenges of making a living on Dublin’s busiest road.

    By Samuel Adeleke 

    I Citizens’ concerns in Dublin are usually centered on motorists and pedestrians. Still, recent statistics from the Road Safety Authority (RSA) shows that the greatest share of serious injuries was among those cycling for social trips, at 76 per cent.    

    In addition, the statistics also revealed that 187 cyclists were seriously injured while commuting to and from work, and the majority of these injuries occurred in Dublin. 

    These figures raise questions about the challenges faced by cyclists in the city center, especially for delivery cyclists whose livelihoods depend on riding these roads daily and who are exposed to different road and weather conditions without the protection of a vehicle. 

    Damilola Foluwashayo, a delivery cyclist with the delivery service Just Eat, said, “Cycling can be tedious when it rains. The roads become slippery, and there is a higher chance of getting a flat tire.”  

    This not only makes riding more difficult but also increases the risk of injury to the rider. 

    “If you ride too fast and want to apply the brakes on a slippery road, you might fall because there is no friction to hold your tires,” Foluwashayo said. 

    One of such fall led to Foluwashayo sustaining a serious injury. “I was trying to avoid two kids playing on the road. In the process, I stepped on the wrong brake, my tires got spoiled, and I broke my leg,” he said.  

    The changeable weather presents other challenges for cyclists. “In the first seconds it’s raining, the next seconds it’s not raining, just always take your safety gears with you and have your lights, lights make you safer,” said Judge Eddy, who uses his bicycle for grocery shopping for his wife. 

    In addition to challenging weather conditions, cyclists also have to deal with careless drivers.  

    “We often encounter reckless drivers on the road,” said Thomas Nve, a delivery cyclist with Deliveroo.  

    “Taxi drivers, in particular, seem determined to meet the metrics and quickly get to their next client,” he added. 

    But other road users criticise delivery riders for breaking the rules.  

    “I have a big thing against delivery riders; they have no lights, they go through red lights all the time, and they tend to just cross over all the time,” said Judge Eddy.  

    Eric Andrel, a delivery cyclist with Deliveroo, attributed an accident he had to the deplorable state of the road.  

    “There have been a lot of potholes because of the rain, I had an accident because the pothole was covered by water,” he said. 

    “The roads are also narrow and don’t give room to swerve safely,” Andrel said. To constantly keep himself safe, Andrel said, “I wear high-visibility clothes and always have my helmet on.” 

    Andrel says The Government should do more to keep all road users safe “They should create a system where, after 6pm, only public transport is allowed in the city.” 

    Mariann Finan, who is an all-year-round cyclist, said conditions have improved for Dublin cyclists, but problems remain.  “In terms of infrastructure for cyclists, it is better than it was; at least we have a lot of cycle lanes now, but they are not really finished. They stop and start, and you don’t really know where the next lane is.”  

    Photo credit: Samuel Adeleke

    Finan also noted a pandemic of wearing headphones among cyclists.  

    “I don’t even know how anybody can wear headphones while cycling, because there is so much going on around you that you need to be alert to,” she said. 

    Finan warns of dangerous overtaking by cyclists. She said: “A lot of the Brazilians and Chinese delivery riders have electric bicycles and tend to overspeed, but they should always use their bells to alert other road users.” 

    Cliff Nolan, the owner of Bike Stops on Capel Street, Dublin, which sells and repairs bicycles, said, “I service a lot of delivery riders’ bicycles. The most recurrent issue with them is a puncture in the tyres, and their brakes always need a lot of attention.” 

    “Delivery riders should always buy quality parts instead of going for cheap parts, which puts them at risk,” Nolan advised. 

    Photo credit: Samuel Adeleke

    One Chinese worker with Deliveroo, who did not wish to be named, said, “There are many dangers on the road. There are robberies by teenagers, and our bicycles are easily stolen.” 

    He also highlighted other issues with the healthcare system that discourages drivers from seeking treatment for injuries.  

    “I have fallen so many times on my bicycle and have had to treat my own wounds,” he claimed.   

    “We generally don’t go to the hospital because going to the hospital will be troublesome and takes a lot of time. We figured we could handle it ourselves, and it would be much faster.” 

    “Cyclists should ensure that both they and their bikes are visible to other road users by investing in good sets of front and rear lights, and by wearing clothing that helps them be seen,” said John Paul Guiheen, the Executive Officer of Communications at the RSA, in an email correspondence.  

    “They should also consider wearing high-visibility materials and obeying the rules of the road,” he added. 

    The RSA stated that there was a deliberate effort last year to inform major food delivery companies about changes to the law concerning electric bicycles as introduced in the Road Traffic and Roads Acts 2023.  

    “Riders must obey the same rules of the road as drivers; the roads are a shared space. Hence, drivers must follow all speed limits, traffic signals, and parking regulations,” said Guiheen.  

    On other issues bothering on weather conditions, cycle lanes, and bicycle theft, the RSA said, “That should be directed to the NTA, local authorities who maintain roads, and the Gardai respectively.” 

     But “during severe weather events, we issue advice to all road users, including cyclists,” he said.

  • The Rise of Road Deaths and the Fall of Speed Limits: Have our Roads Become More Dangerous? 

    The Rise of Road Deaths and the Fall of Speed Limits: Have our Roads Become More Dangerous? 

    by Katie Shadlow 

    As the number of road fatalities in 2024 goes up, the speed limit goes down, but will this be enough to keep people safe on our roads? 

    As of September, according to An Garda Síochána, Irelands national police and security service, the amount of road deaths recorded has been a total of 132. 

    Of the 132 deaths, 52 of these deaths have been drivers, 29 have been passengers, 17 have been motorcyclists, 22 have been pedestrians, eight have been pedal cyclists, and three have been e-scooter drivers. 

    The number of road deaths this year has yet to surpass last year’s number of road deaths, which came to 184, but as we look at previous year’s numbers and the already rapid growth of road deaths this year, we can see that these statistics show no sign of slowing down or decreasing. 

    Between 2022 and 2023, there was a 19% rise in road deaths and fatal road accidents, with the rise in road deaths between 2021 and 2022 also being 19%. 

    Looking at these statistics, we can only hope that the same pattern does not follow in 2024. 

    The hope for safer roads for Irish people was not lost when significant decreases in road deaths were recorded over the last 2 decades, seeing a 55% road death drop from 1997 where 472 people lost their lives on Irish roads, versus in 2010 when this figure dropped to 212. 

    Source: Leitrim Observer 

    As quickly as the number of road deaths decreased, the rise started again.  

    From 2018 on, when recorded road deaths were at the lowest since 1945 at only 138 deaths, the numbers slowly started increasing until 2020, when we see a low of 130 road deaths and fatal collisions.  

    The Covid-19 lockdown is likely to play a big role in the decrease in road deaths for 2020. 

    Since then, the number has yet again been increasing, and precautions have been put in place as of 2024 to combat these rising numbers, but will they be enough?  

    A reduction in Ireland’s national speed limit will begin to take effect in November of 2024. 

    Mary Bolger from Blessington in County Wicklow was involved in a road accident when a drunk driver hit her vehicle in a head on collision just outside the town in 2004..  She questions whether the new lower limit will make a difference.”The problem is the people – if they didn’t mind the speed limit before they won’t mind it now,” she said. 

    Blessington seen a reduction in its speed limits both in and surrounding the town as far back as May. 

    Source: Irish Times. Photograph: Keith Arkins 

    “I know in my case anyway it wasn’t the speed that was the problem – drink driving has become second nature to far too many people from small towns – rural parts,” Mary explained 

    Junior Minister at the Department of Transport James Lawless has said it is the ‘intention’ from November the limit on local roads will fall to 60kph from 80kph. 

    Further limit drops will follow in the new year and are expected to include a fall on national secondary roads from 100kmh to 80km/h and from 50km/h to 30km/h in built-up areas. 

    “It’s definitely a step in the right direction though, so I suppose we can only wait and see how much good it does us,” Mary added. 

    Most road accidents have been recorded in Tipperary and Dublin so far in 2024. Drivers can only hope to see a change in this with the introduction of lower speed limits. 

  • Number of road deaths has increased by nearly 25% from 2015

    Number of road deaths has increased by nearly 25% from 2015

    By Kieva McLaughlin

    Some 163 people have been killed on Irish roads so far in 2016, compared to 131 people at this time last year. Specific figures will not be released until early next year, but trends that were looking optimistic after last year aren’t holding up.

    Wikipedia.jpg
    Source: Wikipedia

    Looking at the figures and statistics on road deaths last year and over the last 10 years can help discover what kind of trends are occurring and who is most at risk.

    Road deaths were the second lowest in Ireland in over half a century in 2015. Mayo had the highest number of fatalities per 100,000 people (10), while Dublin had very few, with just 1.3 per 100,000.

    Dublin (17) and Cork (16) had the highest number of road fatalities in Ireland (because of their high populations) while Roscommon and Waterford both had no road deaths. Cathal Lynch from the RSA said that even though the two counties had no road fatalities last year, “It’s impossible to infer a trend from just one year of data,” so this does not necessarily mean they will continue on this course.

    Some 29% of people who died in 2015 were not wearing seat belts, which could have been the deciding factor in their death.  Almost one in three collisions were alcohol related with even a small amount of alcohol increasing the risk of being involved in a fatal crash. A shocking one in ten drivers (284,000) admitted to drinking before driving in the 12 months prior to November 2015, with 2 out of 5 of these drinking two or more drinks.

    Garda Grace Byrne of Blackrock Garda station said, “People might see the stereotypical drink driver as a man having a few pints after work and then driving home. But I have noticed in recent times that there is an increase in young females being arrested for drink driving.” She has also noticed that there are more people being arrested the morning after, “they’ve been out drinking the night before and are still over the limit the next day, without even realising.”

    Donegal has had the highest number of fatalities for its population continuously in the past decade, with 18.3 per 100,000 in 2005, but is making improvements, going down to almost a third of that in 2015 with 6.8 deaths per 100,000. In the last five years Roscommon has gone from 14 in 2010 (per 100,000 people) to 0 in 2015. Dublin and Cork are steadily getting lower and Galway had a huge drop from 2005 (9.1) to 2010 (2.4) but rose again in 2015 (4.8).

    road-fatalities-2005-to-2015
    Created by: Kieva McLaughlin

    In 2015, the most vulnerable age group was 16- 25 year olds with 27% of all road fatalities. The elderly had the second highest number of road deaths with 19% and the 26-35 year age group closely followed with 17% of all the road fatalities.

    road-3
    Created by: Kieva McLaughlin

    The highest number of road deaths are drivers, totaling 46% of road fatalities in 2015. Vulnerable road users (pedestrian, motorcyclist and pedal cyclist) accounted for 38% of road deaths with the highest number being pedestrians. This was only down 2% in 5 years from 21% in 2010 to 19% in 2015.

    road-4
    Created by: Kieva McLaughlin

    A total of 76 drivers were killed in 2015, this is the same number as 2014 and down from 91 drivers in 2010.

    Younger drivers were most susceptible, accounting for 25% of all drivers killed (16-25 years). The majority of driver fatalities occurred on country roads, and in particular on roads with a higher speed limit (shown below). Garda Grace Byrne thinks the main reason for accidents in Ireland is speed, “Speed is a killer, the faster you are driving and collide with a vehicle the less likely your chances are [of surviving].” As shown below, males accounted for 76% of driver fatalities.

    road-pie-chart
    Created by: Kieva McLaughlin

    Speed Limit No. of Deaths
    30 km/h 1
    50 km/h 6
    60 km/h 6
    80 km/h 31
    100 km/h 29
    120 km/h 3

    Total

    76

    Table 1 (Created by Kieva McLaughlin, Figures Source: RSA)

    In 2014, almost 25,700 people died in European Union countries. Over 200,000 people suffered serious, life changing injuries. However, in 2000 very few EU member states had a fatality rate lower than 8 deaths per 100,000 inhabitants but in 2014 there were only 5 EU countries with a fatality rate higher than that. There were a total of 5,700 less deaths from 2010 – 2014.

    Malta, the Netherlands, the United Kingdom, and Sweden had the lowest number of fatalities, all below 3 deaths per 100,000. Lithuania, Bulgaria, Romania and Latvia had the highest number of road deaths all having 9 or more per 100,000. Latvia had the highest with 10.5 road fatalities per 100,000 people living there.

    The road fatality rate of nearly every country lowered from 2010 to 2014 except Latvia which rose from 10.3 to 10.5 (per 100,000).  Sweden and Lithuania both increased by 0.1 each and Estonia stayed constant at 5.9 deaths (per 100,000).

    The EU average in 2010 was 6.3 and lowered to 5.1 in 2014. Ireland was below the EU average both years going from 4.7 to 4.3. An EU road safety plan wants to reduce the road deaths by half from 2010 to 2020. Although the rate has lowered by around 19% since 2010 it has only lowered 1% from 2013 to 2014. This means the rate is slowing down rather than speeding up, which, if continued at this rate, will not reach the EU’s goal.

    Pedestrian fatalities are not decreasing as much as the overall rate, with 22% of all killed on the roads in 2013 being pedestrians. Pedestrians are at a higher risk in urban areas and the elderly are particularly vulnerable. Ireland was below the EU average at 18%. The Netherlands, Finland, Belgium and France were all below 15% and in Poland, Latvia, Lithuania and Romania over a third of people killed were pedestrians.

    The EU has the lowest fatality rate of any region in the world, with the USA having double its rate at 10.2 (per 100,000) in 2014.

    road-eu
    Created by: Kieva McLaughlin

    Footnote:

    Country Abbreviations: AT Austria, BE Belgium, BG Bulgaria, CY Cyprus, CZ Czech Republic, DE Germany, DK Denmark, EE Estonia, EL Greece, ES Spain, FI Finland, FR France, HR Croatia, HU Hungary, IE Ireland, IT Italy, LT Lithuania, LU Luxembourg, LV Latvia, MT Malta, NL Netherlands, PL Poland, PT Portugal, RO Romania, SI Slovenia, SK Slovakia, SE Sweden, UK United Kingdom.

  • NCT odour debate lingers on

    NCT odour debate lingers on

    On an airing of RTÉ Liveline last month, a man called Connor phoned in about his unusual NCT test experience.

    His vehicle was refused by a tester on the basis of a smell of fish present inside. The caller was a self-employed restaurant owner from Carrickmacross, Co. Monaghan, who occasionally transports fish in the car. He claimed the odour was not strong enough to cause the tester any immediate distress.

    A staff member told him over the phone that a foul or unpleasant smell would be a Health and Safety issue to a tester. As a consequence, Connor was not even given a certificate of failure but did have his fee returned.

    He was contentious about the guideline which mentions vehicle cleanliness. It requires a car to be “reasonably clean”, but it does not mention odours. He also referred to the fact that Applus+ is the only vehicle test company operating in Ireland, which meant he had nowhere else to go.

    A spokesperson for the NCT Customer Service stated that “They should be in the condition that a tester can conduct the test in comfort. Obviously if the smell is too bad, they cannot perform the test and they have the right to stop it.”

    He continued, “In the case of a dispute, you would have to speak to a team leader. They would be able to look at it better than we (at the call centre) would. If there was an issue of smell, they can make a judgment on it.”

    TheCity.ie found some members of the public to react to this, and queried about how fair or unfair these measures are.

    Photo Credits: Caro’s Lines on Flickr

    Video Credits:

    Reporter: Eoin Harmon

    Camera: Kay Cairns

    Production: Kay Cairns